Nate Bargatze's debut film, The Breadwinner, is a missed opportunity for the comedian to showcase his talent beyond the confines of stand-up comedy. While Bargatze's deadpan humor has been a hit on the comedy circuit, his attempt at a family-friendly film falls flat, leaving audiences underwhelmed. The movie's premise, centered around a suburban dad struggling to manage his family's affairs while his wife is away, is a familiar one, but Bargatze's execution lacks the charm and wit that made his stand-up routines so appealing.
One of the main issues with The Breadwinner is its reliance on dated comedy tropes. The film's humor often feels forced and unoriginal, with references to 90s sitcoms and Adam Sandler's mid-2000s era. The character of Nate, played by Bargatze, is a stereotypical suburban dad, and his journey to discover the importance of parenting responsibilities feels uninspired. The movie fails to capture the essence of Bargatze's stand-up style, which is known for its relatability and self-deprecating humor.
The supporting cast, including SNL alumni like Will Forte and Colin Jost, adds a layer of familiarity but doesn't elevate the film. Forte's performance as the bumbling roofer, Keegan, is a highlight, but it's a case of good casting rather than exceptional acting. The movie's attempt to pay homage to the work moms often overlooked in modern families falls flat, as Nate's struggles seem insignificant in the face of the family's affluence.
The film's pacing is another concern. It moves at a snail's pace, with long stretches of uneventful dialogue and unfunny moments. The running gag about the damp towels is a minor bright spot, but it's not enough to save the movie from its overall mediocrity. The movie's meta-humor, such as Nate's corny stand-up routine, feels forced and out of place.
In my opinion, The Breadwinner is a missed opportunity for Nate Bargatze to showcase his comedic genius. The film's reliance on outdated humor and its failure to capture the essence of Bargatze's stand-up style leave audiences feeling disappointed. While the movie has its moments, it ultimately falls short of the mark, and one can't help but wonder if Bargatze's talent is being wasted in this uninspired film. Perhaps it's time for him to explore new avenues and push the boundaries of his comedy, leaving behind the shadows of Sandler and 90s sitcoms.
